B. Roberts or M. Giles?

[futanto]

Who do you think will be a more productive player this year between Brian Roberts and Marcus Giles?

[Pokeyouindaeye]

Unless he gets injured again, Marcus Giles is the man.

[chinch sacs]

Good question, I have both in my league...

If you need the steals, go with Roberts, if you need the RBIs and a few more HRs go with Giles

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

I still think Giles will be the No 2 or 3 2B by the end of the year. Roberts will cost you too much if you're trying to get him in a trade, though.

[futanto]

I have both also. I'll probably squeeze out a little more from Roberts and let Giles ride the bench or take my utility spot in place of tex for a another week or so. Then I'll trade Roberts while his value is still high... but then again I said this a week ago.

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

I have both also. I'll probably squeeze out a little more from Roberts and let Giles ride the bench or take my utility spot in place of tex for a another week or so. Then I'll trade Roberts while his value is still high... but then again I said this a week ago.

If you have both, I'd pull the trigger on a Roberts trade as soon as he shows signs of faltering, but that's just me.

[CubsFan7724]

Way too late to trade for Roberts. Their numbers should be closer than people think, as long as Roberts keeps this up for a decent amount of time. But you'd be insane to not to start him right now.

[tomkatt]

I have them both on my team. Been throwin Marcus Giles in my utility spot.

[warrick95]

Start fielding trade offers for Brian Roberts right now...jump on a big deal. You can make somebody pay. It only takes one to believe.