How good is Melky?

Sleepers, updates, strategy, advice ... if it doesn't fit one of the more specialized categories, it goes right here! (Note: Please do NOT post trade, keeper or 'rate my team' questions - they have separate forums.)

Moderator: Baseball Moderators

Noggy
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 2:38 pm

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by Noggy »

AtlDynasty25 wrote:
bcb wrote:How good is Melky?


Not very.


Steve Phillips, is that you?

Steve Phillips on BBTN wrote:"I like Melky Cabrera for what he is. I think he's a good fourth outfielder, a very good fifth outfielder. I don't see him as an everyday player. Now on the Yankees he can be, because with their offense you can kind of work around him a little bit, but I don't see him as an everyday player on most other teams. He's a role player...Yeah, Melky Cabrera to me is not a reason to not go to the playoffs...I would have explored every possibility of finding a defensive guy to play center field if Melky Cabrera was the sticking point. To me, I don't let Melky Cabrera keep me out of the playoffs if I can bring Eric Gagne in."
chipper
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sat Apr 08, 2006 11:39 pm
Beginner: No
Roster Information: C- VMart
1B- Fielder
2B- Kinsler
3B- M.Cabrera
SS- Y.Escobar
CI- Braun
MI- Polanco
OF- Carlos Lee
OF- Corey Hart
OF- Nate McLouth
Util- Bourn
Util- Nick Johnson
BN- Cameron
BN- Ludwick

SP- Shields
SP- McGowan
RP- Lidge
RP- Percival
P- Rauch
P- Smoltz
P- Chamberlain
BN- Volquez
BN- E.Santana
BN- Floyd

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by chipper »

Steve Phillips continues to sound retarded on an almost daily basis. Only he could make Kruck sound good.
chipper
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sat Apr 08, 2006 11:39 pm
Beginner: No
Roster Information: C- VMart
1B- Fielder
2B- Kinsler
3B- M.Cabrera
SS- Y.Escobar
CI- Braun
MI- Polanco
OF- Carlos Lee
OF- Corey Hart
OF- Nate McLouth
Util- Bourn
Util- Nick Johnson
BN- Cameron
BN- Ludwick

SP- Shields
SP- McGowan
RP- Lidge
RP- Percival
P- Rauch
P- Smoltz
P- Chamberlain
BN- Volquez
BN- E.Santana
BN- Floyd

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by chipper »

kimchi_chigae wrote:I have nothing against Melky Cabrera, but top 20 OF next year for him is a bit of a reach IMHO. I see him more as a .280 than a .300 hitter. His HR total probably will top around 15. I would take Cuddyer easily over Cabrera next year and I don't even like Cuddyer all that much.


Over the last month, he has "out pointed" guys like Carlos Lee, Matt Holliday, Ichiro, etc.....by ALOT.
So while top 20 next year really isn't realistic, Melky is a solid fantasy option, a solid real life option, and to me, more valuable than a guy like Cuddyer.

Also, Melky has batted 9th most of the year. If next year he takes the leadoff spot for good, it gives yet another boost to his value.
User avatar
WharfRat
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 12:55 pm
Beginner: No

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by WharfRat »

I think he can certainly be top 20 in his peak years, but not next year; even so, he's a guy I'd snag for next year though as a 3rd OFer and watch him improve over the next few years. He'll get the playing time and give the production, and he could surprise you. He was a .280 hitter at 21 and he just turned 23, so no reason to think he won't improve on that and other categories.
J35J
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2004 5:18 pm
Beginner: No

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by J35J »

It obviously all depends on the PT he will get. If he is a full time starter in the Yankees lineup he will surely give you good #'s. I haven't gotten into my rankings at all for next year but top 20 OFer seems very unlikely.
buffalobillsrul2002
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 10:03 pm

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by buffalobillsrul2002 »

Is .300/15/15 really that great? Because that's what he'll be next year I think. He could get 90/80 R/RBI at the top of the Yankee lineup, but I think more than that is stretching it. I see him as a solid OF who fills all categories fairly well for you, but doesn't really do anything special....
I guess that's a pretty solid 3rd/4th OF for you in a 12-team league.... but nothing more....
IllinoisBandit
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Thu Apr 29, 2004 11:31 pm

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by IllinoisBandit »

Noggy wrote:
AtlDynasty25 wrote:
bcb wrote:How good is Melky?


Not very.


Steve Phillips, is that you?

Steve Phillips on BBTN wrote:"I like Melky Cabrera for what he is. I think he's a good fourth outfielder, a very good fifth outfielder. I don't see him as an everyday player. Now on the Yankees he can be, because with their offense you can kind of work around him a little bit, but I don't see him as an everyday player on most other teams. He's a role player...Yeah, Melky Cabrera to me is not a reason to not go to the playoffs...I would have explored every possibility of finding a defensive guy to play center field if Melky Cabrera was the sticking point. To me, I don't let Melky Cabrera keep me out of the playoffs if I can bring Eric Gagne in."


God Steve Phillips is so dense. The man should be bagging groceries.
AdvRider
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sat Apr 10, 2004 8:09 pm
Roster Information: C McCann
1B Utley
2B Castillo
3B Chavez
SS Furcal
OF Holliday
OF Griffey
OF Damon
Util Patterson
BN Youkilis, Hall
DL Derek

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by AdvRider »

Somehow I missed this fact earlier, but read today that Cabrera is just ... 23 years old!

In fact, he just turned 23 on Saturday. Wow. Somehow I thought he was like 28. At that tender age playing for NYY he's got some major upside potential. '08 sleeper pick ... ;-)
spamnon
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Sun Mar 28, 2004 10:41 pm
Beginner: No
Roster Information: 10 Person Keeper Roto League (1 hitter, 1 pitcher, 1 hitter/pitcher based on original draft position)
6x6 (add OBP for batters, K : BB for pitchers)

C - snyder
1b - huff
2b - kinsler
ss - s drew
3b - davis
OF - sizemore
OF - crawford
OF - abreu
ut - hart
ut - a-rod
bn - a cabrera
dl - c jackson
dl - ianetta

sp - hamels
sp - cain
sp - zambrano
rp - bell
rp - k-rod
rp - b. wilson
p - harang
p - scherzer
p - carpenter
bn - millwood
bn - lackey
bn - hughes
bn - s marshall
bn - hanson

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by spamnon »

definitely better then damon next year, and the guy who replaced him in boston, crisp!
PlayingWithFire
T-Ball Trainer
Posts: 0
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2005 10:29 pm

Re: How good is Melky?

Post by PlayingWithFire »

blankman wrote:I think he could be a .285-.290 guy and go 15-20. Johnny Damon of years past with fewer steals.


he's on pace for only 11 in 550 ab this year
Post Reply

Return to “Baseball Leftovers”