Page 1 of 1

need help valuing m. cabrera?

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 3:48 pm
by kingman2003
hello,

i just posted this question in the trade, keeper, waiver forum, but since it is not a specific trade i am inquiring into, maybe this is the better forum. if this is the wrong forum let me know.

i am wondering what cabrera's value is in a standard roto league. this is not a keeper league. i ask b/c i want to add a SP to solidify my rotation, and i have tex coming off the DL. it seems to me that now would be a great time to move cabrera.

so what category of starting pitcher should i expect to get in return for cabrera?

i was thinking that the oswalt, wood or hudson category is a stretch. i realize he qualifies at 3rd, and while this does add to his value, 3rd is not a shallow position in my league. virtually every owner has a viable fantasy 3B on their team.

i was thinking that his value may be more in line with the catgory of pitchers like miller, millwood, wolf. maybe i could get a santana or a beckett, but that seems like a bit of a reach.

i also think the webb type of SP may be a little low.

any thoughts would be appreciated. am i in the right frame of mind. thanks.

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 4:28 pm
by John Bonzo
You could probably get a miller, millwood, wolf type pitcher for him. Actually, with Santana's slow start you may be able to get him. Definitely not Beckett or Webb.

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 4:56 pm
by rlee
I recently offered Cabrera and Isringhausen for Bagwell. The other team owner never replied to the offer, so I would assume he was less than enthused (I thought it was fair)

While this doesn't answer your question directly, I would agree that Cabrera alone would be able to fetch a Wolf, Millwood, Miller, type pitcher. He could very well have a 30-110 year if Pierre and Castillo get hot. :*)

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 5:04 pm
by Fantasyballer
if i was the bagwell owner, i would accept that trade without thinking twice. i dont think its fair TO YOUR SIDE. imo, cabrera will end up as good as bagwell and you get a stud closer with that? far to good to pass up.

Penny for your Cabrera

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 5:12 pm
by Rob
I think others will have an equally difficult time valuing Cabrera since he hasn't a full season's resume. If one believes he can continue this pace, then a Miller, Santana, Beckett should be attainable. And of course under perfect circumstances, trade partner is desperate and has the pitching depth, an upper tier pitcher could be had. Personally, I would be willing to offer up a Penny, Maddux, Escobar, Pineiro type of pitcher. I'd shoot for Penny, think he's turned a corner in his career and could be consistent.

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 8:18 pm
by orangecrushv
i've also been pondering trading cabrera, what type of hitter would you expect to be able to trade for?

-rich

PostPosted: Tue Apr 27, 2004 9:00 pm
by Bedard
Don't even think about trading Miguel Cabrera for Johan Santana. Trust me, you're better than that.