| Rank | First Name | Last Name | Team |
| 1 | Clayton | Kershaw | Dodgers |
| 2 | Max | Scherzer | Nationals |
| 3 | Chris | Sale | White Sox |
| 4 | Jake | Arrieta | Cubs |
| 5 | Madison | Bumgarner | Giants |
| 6 | Carlos | Carrasco | Indians |
| 7 | Jacob | deGrom | Mets |
| 8 | Stephen | Strasburg | Nationals |
| 9 | Noah | Syndergaard | Mets |
| 10 | David | Price | Red Sox |
| 11 | Corey | Kluber | Indians |
| 12 | Chris | Archer | Rays |
| 13 | Matt | Harvey | Mets |
| 14 | Gerrit | Cole | Pirates |
| 15 | Zack | Greinke | Dodgers |
| 16 | Jose | Fernandez | Marlins |
| 17 | Dallas | Keuchel | Astros |
| 18 | Felix | Hernandez | Mariners |
| 19 | Jon | Lester | Cubs |
| 20 | Danny | Salazar | Indians |
| 21 | Johnny | Cueto | Giants |
| 22 | Masahiro | Tanaka | Yankees |
| 23 | Cole | Hamels | Rangers |
| 24 | Francisco | Liriano | Pirates |
| 25 | Garrett | Richards | Angels |
| 26 | Carlos | Martinez | Cardinals |
| 27 | Raisel | Iglesias | Reds |
| 28 | Tyson | Ross | Padres |
| 29 | Justin | Verlander | Tigers |
| 30 | Hisashi | Iwakuma | Mariners |
| 31 | Adam | Wainwright | Cardinals |
| 32 | Yu | Darvish | Rangers |
| 33 | Yordano | Ventura | Royals |
| 34 | Jose | Quintana | White Sox |
| 35 | Patrick | Corbin | Diamondbacks |
| 36 | Marcus | Stroman | Blue Jays |
| 37 | Jake | Odorizzi | Rays |
| 38 | Jeff | Samardzija | Giants |
| 39 | Clay | Buchholz | Red Sox |
| 40 | Drew | Smyly | Rays |
| 41 | Carlos | Rodon | White Sox |
| 42 | Ian | Kennedy | Royals |
| 43 | Taijuan | Walker | Mariners |
| 44 | Michael | Pineda | Yankees |
| 45 | Steven | Matz | Mets |
| 46 | Michael | Wacha | Cardinals |
| 47 | Sonny | Gray | Athletics |
| 48 | Gio | Gonzalez | Nationals |
| 49 | James | Shields | Padres |
| 50 | Scott | Kazmir | Dodgers |
| 51 | John | Lackey | Cubs |
| 52 | Collin | McHugh | Astros |
| 53 | Wei-Yin | Chen | Marlins |
| 54 | Lance | McCullers | Astros |
| 55 | Jason | Hammel | Cubs |
| 56 | Shelby | Miller | Diamonbacks |
| 57 | Jaime | Garcia | Cardinals |
| 58 | Kevin | Gausman | Orioles |
| 59 | Rich | Hill | Athletics |
| 60 | Joe | Ross | Nationals |
| 61 | Luis | Severino | Yankees |
| 62 | Matt | Moore | Rays |
| 63 | Kyle | Hendricks | Cubs |
| 64 | Mike | Fiers | Astros |
| 65 | Julio | Teheran | Braves |
| 66 | Kyle | Gibson | Twins |
| 67 | Anibal | Sanchez | Tigers |
| 68 | Jordan | Zimmermann | Tigers |
| 69 | Kenta | Maeda | Dodgers |
| 70 | Erasmo | Ramirez | Rays |
| 71 | J.A. | Happ | Blue Jays |
| 72 | Eduardo | Rodriguez | Red Sox |
| 73 | Hyun-Jin | Ryu | Dodgers |
| 74 | Lucas | Giolito | Nationals |
| 75 | Jose | Berrios | Twins |
| 76 | Jimmy | Nelson | Brewers |
| 77 | Tyler | Duffey | Twins |
| 78 | Andrew | Heaney | Angels |
| 79 | Andrew | Cashner | Padres |
| 80 | Nathan | Eovaldi | Yankees |
| 81 | Josh | Tomllin | Indians |
| 82 | Aaron | Nola | Phillies |
| 83 | Daniel | Norris | Tigers |
| 84 | Trevor | Bauer | Indians |
| 85 | Vincent | Velasquez | Phillies |
| 86 | Edinson | Volquez | Royals |
| 87 | Anthony | DeSclafani | Reds |
| 88 | Alex | Wood | Dodgers |
| 89 | John | Lamb | Reds |
| 90 | R.A. | Dickey | Blue Jays |
| 91 | Mike | Leake | Diamondbacks |
| 92 | Jake | Peavy | Giants |
| 93 | Chris | Heston | Giants |
| 94 | Alex | Cobb | Rays |
| 95 | Ervin | Santana | Twins |
| 96 | Derek | Holland | Rangers |
| 97 | Homer | Bailey | Reds |
| 98 | Mat | Latos | White Sox |
| 99 | Wade | Miley | Mariners |
| 100 | Zack | Wheeler | Mets |
Fantasy Baseball Cafe
Most Accurate MLB Experts Past 4 Years